Skip to content
Direct Ideas

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: The Baroque Master’s Dynamic Portrait of Magdalene.

One woman leans her head back. Eyes closed, her mouth is closed, yet she is alert. Sporting flushed cheeks and vermilion lips, her long blonde hair catches the glow from a nearby candle, casting a incandescent aura in an predominantly gloomy space. She wears ranges from a lace-trimmed blouse—falling down one arm to reveal alabaster skin—to a rich gold and violet cloth. Seemingly by herself, unaware of any viewer, existing in a state of profound liberation.

An Important Institutional First

The subject is Mary Magdalene experiencing rapture, crafted in the 1620s by the Italian Baroque artist Gentileschi. Recently acquired by the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC, it is set to go on exhibition from 24 February. This marks the gallery’s first acquisition of a work by the artist, and curator Letizia Treves has observed that it depicts the saint as “neither repentant nor suffering”. That represents an important difference, for generations, Magdalene’s image has been formed not only by scripture but mythologized and conflated by powerful male figures.

“The most flexible woman in religious painting,” according to a scholar has noted.

Look at portrayals of her and you will see a thinker, orator, disciple, and witness; crying at the base of the crucifix, anointing Jesus’s feet, or gazing heavenward—frequently repenting with pearl-like tears and, too often, revealing her chest. Sometimes recognized by a jar of ointment or a scarlet cloak—unlike the Virgin Mary’s azure—she is most popularly known today as a prostitute, even though not a single biblical verse labeling her as such.

The Layers of Interpretation

“Honestly, we cannot be certain who she was,” said the expert. “Consequently, numerous layers of interpretation have been placed upon her. The shifts she experiences, both visually but narratively, in worship, theologically, are as much related to cultural attitudes and religious changes as they are to belief.” So what do we understand?

Mary Magdalene is mentioned in the New Testament twelve times. Initially, she has evil spirits cast out from her; the rest, she is seen at Christ’s crucifixion and is the primary witness to experience his rising. It is she who proclaims the “good news”. The sensual and sinful legacy can mostly be traced to a sermon delivered in the late sixth century by Pope Gregory the Great, who combined her with Mary of Bethany and an anonymous sinner who bathed Christ’s feet with her tears.

By lumping them together, Pope Gregory effectively “created” the repentant fallen woman—a myth additionally elaborated by later church fathers and medieval legends. Painters and sculptors took note, and in a largely illiterate but image-savvy world, this proved highly impactful. The “seven demons” became the “seven deadly sins”, cementing her primary narrative as one of moral lapse and subsequent salvation—solidified in paintings and sculptures that continue to influence perceptions today.

Centuries of Penitence and Objectification

From Donatello’s gaunt, wooden Magdalene wringing her hands in penitence, to Caravaggio’s 1606 portrayal of her devoid of life and on the brink of death—not to mention Rubens’ semi-nude, possessed Magdalene supported by angels. Mary Magdalene has frequently been diminished sexually. Albrecht Dürer’s print showed her demurely, with flowing hair draping her unclothed body, while another’s version looks heavenward, with tearful eyes and carefully placed hands exposing her breasts.

Evidently, anguish and sexualization were the primary extremes in her representation: she could serve as a warning against sin, be the exemplar for contrition, while offering artists a excuse to depict semi-nudity veiled as devotion. This “fallen woman redeemed” narrative endured for centuries—so profoundly that asylums called “Magdalene laundries” subjected women into unpaid labor, systems that astonishingly only closed a mere thirty years ago.

Through a Woman’s Eyes

But what if there was another side to her narrative? Imagine if her journey could be one of spiritual awakening and transformation, where she was shown as full of life, joy, and sublimity? In other words, what if we saw her via the eyes of a woman?

This is what Artemisia accomplishes. Her portrait is not posing for the viewer; she is not weeping, not repenting, without shame, not sexualized, and not dictating a sermon. Rather, she has rosy cheeks and is, as described, “vibrantly living … in the grip of divine joy”. An expert stated that Gentileschi “endows Mary Magdalene with an dynamic vitality”.

“It is an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her moment of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … spoken of at times as if it’s the finest sexual encounter … the greatest ecstasy she could ever have. It’s beautiful, it’s bodily, it’s sexual, it’s transcendent. One is raised beyond oneself to a higher level.”

Frequently, when female artists portray biblical or mythological women, they show them not as passive, sinful, ashamed, or inferior, but as agentic, multifaceted, and with minds of their own: “Women with a capital ‘W’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Therefore, while this new acquisition might ultimately be redressing a gender disparity at the institution, its significance extends further. It changes not just how we perceive biblical and mythological women, but also the understanding of womanhood at large.

This perspective is one the Catholic church in time acknowledged. In the late 1960s, it officially recognized her official role as a faithful follower rather than a sinful repenter. As recently as 2016, the pontiff elevated her ranking to “the apostle of apostles”, marking a day in July as her celebration. This indicates that, as institutions evolve, perspectives are shifting. This acquisition—portraying a figure free from a patriarchal gaze, living for herself, not suffering nor sensationalised—is a component in a larger movement towards a more balanced representation.

About the author

Christina Thomas

Tech strategist and innovation consultant with over a decade of experience helping startups scale.

Direct Ideas

Type to search articles.